
To the person who keeps saying 'I'm fine'
Published · Reading time: about 8 minutes
Written by Alan Malt · BACP Member 422583
People often arrive here believing they should have coped better. My hope is that, for the next few minutes, you don't have to prove anything. You don't need the right words, or even a clear explanation.
"How are you?"
"I'm fine."
It is the easiest, most automatic lie we tell. We say it to colleagues while waiting for the kettle to boil, to friends over a quick coffee, to family members who call on a Sunday afternoon. We say it so often, and so smoothly, that sometimes we even manage to convince ourselves, for a few minutes at least, that it is actually true.
If you are reading this, I imagine you have become exceptionally good at saying you are fine when you are actually, quietly, falling apart inside. You have perfected the mask. You know exactly how much to smile, exactly how to deflect the conversation back to the other person, and exactly how to make sure nobody looks at you quite long enough to see the cracks.
There is always a tiny, barely perceptible pause before you answer that question. In that fraction of a second, your mind runs a rapid calculation. It assesses the person asking, the environment you are in, and the amount of emotional energy you currently possess.
You think, "Can I tell them the truth?" And then the immediate follow-up arrives: "No, it's too complicated to explain. No, they have their own problems to deal with. No, I don't want to bring the mood down. No, they would not understand anyway. No, if I start talking about it, I might start crying, and I do not know how I will stop."
So you smile, you adjust your posture, and you say you are fine. You ask them how their weekend was, and the moment passes. You are safe. But you are also entirely alone with what you are carrying.
There are many complex reasons why we build this protective shell around ourselves. Perhaps you grew up in a house where difficult emotions were simply not welcome. Where sadness was seen as an inconvenience, anger was punished, or where you had to remain relentlessly cheerful just to keep the peace and balance the turbulent moods of the adults around you. You learned, very early on, that being 'fine' was the safest, most acceptable way to exist in the world.
Perhaps you look at your life right now, your home, your health, your job, your family, and you think, "I have absolutely no right to complain. Other people have it so much worse."
You weigh your internal pain against the external facts of your life, you look at the ledger, and you decide that your feelings are not justified. You tell yourself you are just being ungrateful, or dramatic, or weak. You decide that you have not earned the right to be struggling, and so you force yourself to carry on as though you are not.
The problem with constantly insisting you are fine is that it builds an invisible, soundproof wall between you and the rest of the world.
When you never let anyone see the parts of you that are struggling, you deny them the opportunity to truly know you. You might have a wide circle of friends, a loving partner, and a calendar full of social events, yet still feel profoundly, achingly lonely.
Loneliness does not always mean being physically alone in a room. It more often means being surrounded by people, but hiding the truth of who you are and how you feel. It is the loneliness of knowing that people love the performance you are giving them, but having no idea if they would still love the messy, exhausted reality behind it.
This creates a terrible dynamic in your closest relationships. You might find yourself feeling disconnected from your partner, because the version of yourself you present to them is heavily edited. You might feel a quiet resentment building towards friends who talk endlessly about their own problems, failing to notice that you are drowning. But they do not notice, because you have spent years expertly ensuring that they cannot see the water.
It takes an enormous amount of physical and mental energy to keep the mask firmly in place. It is a full-time job that you perform on top of your actual life.
It is like walking around all day holding your breath. You are constantly monitoring your own reactions, ensuring your voice sounds light enough, your face looks relaxed enough, and your answers are acceptable enough.
By the time you finally get home, close the front door, and drop the act, you are entirely depleted. The sheer effort of appearing normal leaves you with absolutely nothing left for the things that actually matter to you. You might find yourself collapsing on the sofa, unable to do anything more than stare at a screen, utterly devoid of the energy required to engage with your own life.
Your body also bears the cost of this performance. Suppressed emotion does not evaporate; it simply finds somewhere else to go. It becomes the tension in your neck, the shallow breathing in your chest, the digestive issues that doctors cannot quite explain, or the insomnia that keeps you awake long after you have exhausted yourself. Your body is trying to process what your mouth refuses to say.
When we suppress the difficult emotions, the sadness, the fear, the anger, we cannot do so selectively. You cannot numb the bad feelings without also numbing the good ones. The mechanism that dampens pain also dampens joy.
Over time, constantly being 'fine' leads to a slow creep of apathy. Life begins to feel flat, grey, and two-dimensional. You might notice that you no longer feel genuine joy, excitement, or passion for things you used to love. You are simply existing in a neutral, highly controlled middle ground, trying desperately not to feel too much of anything at all.
Sometimes, you might catch yourself caught in a strange fantasy. You imagine someone looking at you, really looking at you, seeing through the smile, and saying, "You're not fine at all, are you?"
You fantasise about someone seeing through the act without you having to explain it, because the effort of explaining feels too heavy to bear. You want to be found out, but you are too terrified to raise your hand and say where you are hiding.
But you are a very good actor. And people generally prefer the performance, because it demands nothing of them. If you want to be seen, you eventually have to take the risk of showing yourself.
I want to offer a gentle, firm challenge to the idea that you have to justify your pain.
Pain is not a competition. There is no global ledger where your distress is measured against someone else's to see if it qualifies for support. If something hurts, it hurts. If you feel empty, you feel empty. If you are struggling to get through the day, that is real, regardless of how comfortable and privileged your life looks from the outside.
You do not have to earn the right to feel sad. You do not have to endure a catastrophe to deserve a space to talk about how heavy life feels.
It is exhausting to live a life where you are constantly auditing your own emotions, trying to logic yourself out of feeling the way you feel. The feelings do not go away because you tell them they are unreasonable. They simply sink deeper into your body, becoming heavier and harder to carry.
Imagine, just for a moment, a space where "I'm fine" is not required.
Imagine sitting in a room where you do not have to manage the impression you are making. Where, when the person asks how you are, you can say, "I am barely holding on today," and the person sitting opposite you does not panic. They do not try to rush you into feeling better, they do not offer you a cheerful platitude, and they do not judge you for failing to keep it together.
They simply sit with you, in the reality of how hard it is.
Therapy is a place to practice taking the mask off. It is a place to finally let the breath out. For someone who is always fine, the first few sessions can feel incredibly vulnerable. You might still try to smile through the painful parts. You might apologise for taking up space.
But gradually, you realise that the counsellor is not asking you for a performance. You do not have to drop the whole brave face all at once. You can take it down slowly, inch by inch, testing the water to see that it is actually safe.
You can discover, gradually, that you are still acceptable, still worthy of care, and that you will not be abandoned when you finally tell the truth about how hard you have been working to seem okay. You learn that your mess, your grief, and your exhaustion are not things to be hidden; they are just parts of being human.
You have spent so much time convincing the world that you are fine. You are allowed to finally admit that, right now, you are not. And you do not have to figure out how to fix it before you say it.
If any part of this felt familiar, perhaps we could explore it together when you're ready.
"If any part of this felt familiar, perhaps we could explore it together when you're ready."
